Why VA claim denials often contradict your own evidence

The VA denied your claim. The letter cites your service records, your C&P exam, or your medical history. It sounds official. It sounds thorough. It often isn't. VA denial letters are frequently built on selective reading of your own evidence — pulling the parts that support denial while ignoring or underweighting the parts that support your claim. This is one of the most common patterns in successful VA appeals. Here's what to look for.

1. The C&P exam report vs. what you actually said

The Compensation and Pension exam is where the VA's examiner evaluates your condition. The problem: what the examiner writes and what you told them are not always the same. Check whether the C&P report accurately reflects the frequency and severity of your symptoms as you described them, whether the examiner noted limitations that match your actual functional impairment, and whether the 'less likely than not' language used to deny service connection holds up against your service records. Red flag: a C&P report that says your condition is 'less likely than not' related to service when your service records document the exact injury or exposure that caused it.

2. The denial letter vs. your service records

The denial letter will often cite your service records as the basis for denial. But service records are rarely complete — especially for older veterans or those who served in combat environments where documentation was inconsistent. Check whether the denial cites an absence of evidence as if it's evidence of absence, and whether it references records known to be incomplete for your era or branch. Red flag: 'No record of in-service event' as the basis for denial when your Military Occupational Specialty (MOS) or deployment history makes the exposure presumptively likely.

3. The rating decision vs. the diagnostic code

When the VA assigns a disability rating, they use a Diagnostic Code from the VA Schedule for Rating Disabilities. The rating must match the criteria for that code. Check whether your rating percentage matches the criteria described in the Diagnostic Code for your condition — if the code requires 'one major episode per year' for a 30% rating and you have documented episodes monthly, does your rating reflect that? Red flag: a rating that applies a lower percentage tier when your documented symptoms clearly meet the criteria for the next tier up.

4. The nexus letter vs. the VA's conclusion

A nexus letter from your private physician linking your condition to your service is supposed to be given significant weight. Often it isn't. Check whether the VA acknowledged your nexus letter in the denial, whether they explained why they gave it less weight than the C&P examiner's opinion, and whether their explanation is internally consistent. Red flag: a denial that ignores a favorable private nexus letter without explaining the reasoning.

5. Total disability based on individual unemployability (TDIU)

If your service-connected disabilities prevent you from maintaining substantially gainful employment, you may be entitled to a 100% rating even if your combined rating is lower. Check whether the VA considered TDIU if your combined rating is 60% or higher (or 70% with one condition at 40%), and whether any denial letter addressed your inability to work — or simply ignored it. You served. Your claim deserves to be read the way a VSO or appeals attorney would read it — every line, every contradiction, every gap.

What ScrubMyCase catches

When you upload a VA denial letter, C&P exam report, or rating decision, ScrubMyCase flags statements in the denial that contradict evidence in the same document, C&P conclusions that don't match the symptom history you provided, rating percentages that don't align with the criteria for the assigned Diagnostic Code, nexus letters acknowledged but dismissed without adequate reasoning, and TDIU eligibility that appears to have been overlooked.

Questions

This guide is general information, not legal advice. For your specific situation, talk to a licensed attorney.

More guides